COMMENTS ON CONSULTANCY: THE CASE OF ST. GEORGE’S – TOWER HAMLETS.

Southwark Council ordered a Consultancy to compare and study the way in which Seven Islands operates.

As indicated before, previous to the consultancy Southwark Council ran the facility in to the ground making it function without ventilation risking the health of the users as employees were entitled to open windows and doors in winter, taking away the diving boards, closing the mothers and toddlers small pool and basically not spending anything on Seven Islands Leisure Centre until the desired consultancy had been performed, and of course the same advises that a large amount of money must be spent.

The consultant estimates that to fully refurbish Seven Islands 8 million pounds would be required. However after obtaining this report now Southwark is going to spend 2 million pounds on the condemned Leisure Centre.

So in this document we want to compare our facility at Seven Islands with the very similar one, also with a 33 meter pool at St. Georges – Tower Hamlets.

Our own consultancy: The similar case of St. George’s Pools in Tower Hamlets:

This is an example of a pool which will have a similar client base as our leisure centre in Rotherhithe when the Master Plan has been implemented.
It will be composed of a considerable amount of local workers, extended amount of school children and young people and a larger amount of residents.
So finally this is the ultimate comparison with our closest competitor: St. Georges in Tower Hamlets on The Highway, the other side of Rotherhithe Tunnel.
You can see for yourself the degree of under-investment at Seven Islands over many years simply by visiting their website: http://www.better.org.uk/st-georges-leisure-centre/facilities
Just like our pool, St. Georges is an Imperial Pool or a 33 meter pool, so to swim one of the most common competition distances of 100 meters 3 lengths are required.
During the Olympics it was the home base of the Russian Synchronous Swimming Team.
Tom Daley teaches people how to dive there BECAUSE unlike Southwark they have kept and updated their diving boards!
Schools and the general public as in our pool mix quite easily because of its longer length and is not a frustrating 18 meters only for the general public when the shallow end is cordoned off for lessons.
This frustrating18 meters is what we would find if it were a mere Standard European/ International 25 meter pool and the shallow end is cordoned off for lessons.
St. Georges pools are very well used, timetables are fixed and it has a big intake of workers from the City who swim there before going in to work and during their lunch hour and after work, so to promote health and physical activity it opens between 7 am and 9 pm.
Unlike Southwark, it has a smaller teaching pool, very practical and useful for smaller children and for teaching and is of a generous size.
Unlike Southwark school children aren’t the only main beneficiaries of a policy to promote physical activity, the pool is also intended for adults and for children who are good swimmers too.
Unlike Southwark St. Georges were the last to introduce a membership fee and also their access costs have always been historically lower than at Seven Islands.

This fantastic pool at St. Georges may not be an Olympic pool but if Southwark Council were to replace our 33 metre pool by a paltry 25 meter pool, then St. Georges would be for all of us the best pool in the area and swimmers from Rotherhithe would obviously prefer the longer Imperial pool at St. Georges to the “new” European standard 25 meters one with hardly any depth.
The effect of Southwark under-investment in the health of its population couldn’t be more marked when comparing both sites and their policies. The different timetables and their stability alone speak volumes.

Now that Seven Islands seems to be condemned, and a suitable negative consultancy report has been provided which more or less assures the Council that it will be able to perform the land grab of the valuable land of Seven Islands Leisure Centre for development, Southwark is going to invest 2 million pounds in to Seven Islands Leisure centre!

This investment is to keep the Centre going for up to 5 years, and though this document mentions that then the Council will determine what use to give the Seven Islands site, the site had been listed already by the Council for development. This listing was a cause for complaint in consultation meetings as it confirms our impression that the consultation is really only a formality.

No comments:

Post a Comment